1826 Valley Hi Road
Jefferson City, MO 65109
(573) 635-2382

Get Map
Cotter Pin Home Image

Welcome To Cotter Pin Cellar

Welcome to Cotter Pin Cellar, your Mid-Missouri source for the largest selection of Genuine Fiesta Dinnerware, farmhouse decor, Amy Howard One-Step Paint products and chalk painted furniture. Whether you're looking for something for your own home, a gift for a loved one, or registering for that "special" occasion, we're committed to providing you with the best of the Fiesta and gifts for all occasions.  Our shop is at a convenient location just outside of Jefferson City. Take a moment to browse our catalog, use our easy registration page, or contact us with your questions. We're more than happy to assist you with all we can.  Bridal and Gift Registries are Welcome!

Latest Happenings

We have moved and have new hours effective May 1, 2021.  Our new location is 1500 East McCarty St, Jefferson City, MO.  Same phone 573-635-2382.
New hours:  Wed - Fri:   10AM-5:30PM
                    Saturday:   10AM-4PM
                    Sunday:     12Noon-4PM
                    Closed:      Monday & Tuesday

We have a great selection of Fiesta, refurbished and chalk painted furniture, farmhouse decor, Amy Howard Paint & Finishes, antiques and vintage. 

Stop in to visit, we look forward to seeing you.

If you have any questions, email us at cotterpincellar@gmail.com.

Fiesta Dinnerware Peggy Karr