Welcome To Cotter Pin Cellar

Welcome to Cotter Pin Cellar, your Mid-Missouri source for the largest selection of Genuine Fiesta Dinnerware. You will also see farmhouse decor, Amy Howard One-Step Paint products, chalk painted furniture, antiques and vintage. Whether you're looking for something for your own home, a gift for a loved one, or registering for that "special" occasion, we're committed to providing you with the best of the Fiesta and gifts for all occasions.  Take a moment to browse our catalog, use our easy registration page, or contact us at (573)635-2382 with any questions. We're more than happy to assist you.  Bridal and Gift Registries are always available!


Fiesta's 2024 Color is "Sky". Will be available for purchase around the end of April to May.

View Products

Amy Howard Paint and Finishes

Amy Howard At Home is the leading manufacturer of certifiable green, artisan quality paint & DIY furniture refinishing products.

See Details

Repurposed/Upcycled Furniture

All our furniture is repurposed and upcycled so it is usually one of a kind. The inventory constantly changes so stop by often and see what is new.

See Details

Farmhouse Decor

We have bread boards, dough bowls, farmhouse furniture and much more. Stop in and check it out.

See Details

Latest Happenings

Stop in to see our large selection of Fiesta dinnerware and accessories. We have the best selection in the area.

You will also find refurbished chalk painted furniture, farmhouse decor, Amy Howard paints & finishes, antiques and vintage items.

Shop early for the best selection. We look forward to seeing you.

If you have any questions, email us at cotterpincellar@gmail.com or phone (573) 635-2382.